Tuesday, June 18, 2013

A Final Reflection-


When I initially enrolled in this class, my children remarked favorably on my long-overdue foray into the digital environment.  While I owned a smart phone, communicated via email, maintained a profile on professional networking sites, and spent considerable time encouraging my staff to adopt new technologies, my personal use of technology remained limited and clouded by ignorance. I certainly could be classified as a “networked worker,” however, my ability to analyze and think critically about technology and its impact on my personal and professional life emerged throughout my readings and writings in this course. Thus, developing a blog became the first of many new learning experiences I engaged in as part of this course. 

Applying the Learning to My Professional Environment

Subsequent to the development of the blog, I began an intentional exploration of the personal technology tools that may enhance my effectiveness as a leader.  Over the past seven weeks, I found myself exploring technology as a mechanism for enhancing our organizational effectiveness.   I began questioning more intentionally the investments our institution was making into new technologies and I engaged our digital adult learning division with more interest and insight.  Specifically, I enrolled in the course our institution required for all faculty aspiring to teach online.  As I became more intentionally immersed in the technology shaping higher education, I became more cognitively aware of the important role leaders play in shaping technology strategy and thereby institutional outcomes. In my new institutional role, I realized that the previous administration’s decision to exclude the chief information officer from the executive leadership team had stifled institutional growth by encouraging haphazard technology investments, rather than embracing technology as a critical component of the institutional strategic planning and budgeting process.  Over the past eight weeks, I invited our chief information technology officer to the executive team and his team will be intimately involved in our new planning initiatives.  In the absence of presence at the executive leadership level, technology decision-making failed to align with the university’s strategic objectives.

Application of the Learning to Ethical Principles

The initial readings in week one provided contrasting perspectives on the impact of the flattened world on humanity.  Friedman (2007) provided evidence from the emerging economies of India, China, and other parts of Southeast Asia to suggest that a flatter world allowed more individuals access to opportunity, which thereby, strengthened struggling economies and facilitated the growth of a middle class.  In contrast, the Florida (2005) article asserted that the beneficiaries of a flattened economy were limited to a few players in the global marketplace.  While opportunities have strengthened cities like Bangalore or Gurgaon, most people across the world still lacked access to the benefits of globalization 3.0.  This contrasting analysis raised important issues of economic and social justice.  As the readings expanded throughout the course, much evidence suggested that technology continues to grow at unprecedented rates (Freidman, 2007).  From Google glasses to Dow Corning’s vision for future kitchens, technology has rapidly proliferated.  If economies continue to struggle with providing basic needs, the likelihood that many individuals can continue to make investments in the quickly emerging technologies remains questionable.  Do the rapid changes shaping technology suffocate the opportunities for the masses to access this emerging technology and truly seize new opportunities?  Do the resource-constrained livelihoods of many in the developing world limit an individual’s ability to garner the advantage of globalization 3.0?  Clearly, the emergence of new technologies provides access for millions to connect, network, and access knowledge that otherwise would not have been possible.  However, access to knowledge and the ability to translate that knowledge into economic opportunity are two distinct issues.  My growing concern is that the rapidity with which technology development is evolving limits access to those individuals or organizations that have the financial means to transform the knowledge into innovation.  Domestically, leadership and public policy have a critical role to play in ensuring equity of opportunity in the public schools systems of America.  Providing young people with the knowledge of how to use and access emerging technologies will be critical to expanding their opportunities in the future.  Globally, leaders must consider the ramifications of their investments on the citizenry of the developing world. 

Application to Leadership

Perhaps most notably, the readings throughout the course reminded me of the important role critical and collaborative thinking, learning and leadership play in our response to emerging technologies.  Fundamentally, the technology is only as good as the user.  Ultimately, we may be able to access millions of terabytes of information, but transforming that information into useful knowledge requires individuals skilled with sophisticated abilities to discern critically reliable, valid, and relevant information from a myriad of sources. One must be careful that in our quest to access information, we do not become victims of “group think” and unable to creatively problem-solve.  We can rely on our network of collaborators to contribute to problem solving, but we must be wary of the consequences of failing to think independently and instead copying the ideas of others.  Collaboration does not imply copying.  Rather, it implies direct interaction with the problem and an engagement of potential solutions with other networks of experts.   Creative thinking still requires an ability to focus, delve deep into an issue, and generate a response to a difficult question.  Unfocused searching for answers, fleeting investments in problem solving, and an inability to develop original thoughts and ideas yields mediocre outcomes.  Douglas Engelbart, an early technology innovator, suggested “The grand challenge is to boost the collective IQ of organizations and of society” (Gruber, 2008).  To achieve this end, technology must maximize access to knowledge and humans must be prepared to actively engage, sort, and discern the usefulness of the resulting findings. Thus, the human and machine must “each do what they do best” (Gruber, 2008, p. 5).  

Fundamentally, technology will continue to change the course of humanity.  Whether those changes manifest themselves as a greater divide between the rich and poor, or alternatively as a pathway of opportunity for the masses depend upon leadership.  Effective leaders understand the importance of integrating technology into our education systems and organizations, promoting learning and work environments that value the ability to create new ideas, delve deeply into subjects of substance, critically and collaboratively engage information, and make decisions that use sound ethical judgments.   If leaders demonstrate ability to value new ways of working, networking, and collaborating, they will be able to seize emerging opportunities and gain competitive advantages.  Access to technology and support of education systems that leverage this technology in the learning process will be critical to improving opportunity both domestically and across the globe. 

Sources:

Gruber, T. (2008).  Collective knowledge systems:  Where the social web meets the semantic web.  Journal of Web Semantics, 6, 4-13. 

Florida, R. (2005, October).  The world is spiky.  The Atlantic Monthly. 

Friedman, T. L. (2007).  The world is flat.  New York, NY:  Picador.

 

8 comments:

  1. Amy, I hope your children approve of the job that I did! :-)

    Your decision to add the CIO to your executive team is solid from my perspective...and I am glad this course edged you in that direction. I particularly appreciated and welcomed the measured view you brought to this course. Your comment that collective learning does not abdicate independent thinking is spot on!

    Best of luck to you and your institution in the future. If I can be of help, call/tweet/email - I am now part of your network!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Britt!
      You pushed me in a new direction, so I certainly appreciate your nudge! I would love to stay connected. I would love to visit sometime about the course you offer to train faculty to teach in the online environment. As I have been taking our course, I am cognizant of areas that may be much improved. Perhaps I could connect and gather insight about the approach you use in creating a collaborative, technology-rich learning environment.

      Best,
      Amy

      Delete
    2. Heading out on vacation next week, but maybe later we could Skype and discuss. You can find a lot of info about our programs at http://www.vcu.edu/cte/resources/TeachingOnline/index.htm

      Britt

      Delete
  2. Amy,

    As always you provide a wonderful and enlightened look at how your journey in this short eight week period has already begun to expand and grow outside of your immediate sphere of direct influence.

    Recognizing the role of the CIO and their team in your processes and that they need to be a part of the process to ensure that the right amount of appropriate resources are being applied vice the haphazard shotgun approach of just getting all the tools in hopes that eventually you find the right one.

    I have to admit that as I was reading your list of application to leadership skills and hit the cooperative thinking section about it is not about copying but building upon each idea, I immediately got the visual of the old Reese's Peanut Butter Cups where two great things accidentally merge into something even better.

    Thanks for giving us insight into your world and sharing your ideas and concepts. I have taken away some wonderful material that I hope I can intentionally bump into my own and come up with something even better.

    Best of luck where ever this journey takes you.

    Marc

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Marc! I love the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup analogy! I think that has a great deal of application to technology and to our efforts to engage our world from a collaborative lens. Marc, I have likewise appreciated your insights.

    Best of luck in the future-

    ReplyDelete
  4. To: Emerging Trends in Higher Education
    From: NotSocrates

    Wow! I am impressed. The post about your learnings embodies exactly what we need to do to lead in this technological era. First, your post demonstrates that you do indeed have the passion for learning. You seem to have constantly stepped out of the box to learn about, and more importantly, integrate technology into your life. I am also impressed by the fact that you invited the CIO to join you at the table so they are involved in new planning initiatives. This is a great step and a critical one if strategic thinking is to take place at the organizational level.

    I do want to comment on what you (or Gruber) refer to as “the grand challenge”. I myself agree with Freeman, IQ is only part of the battle. As leaders it is important to also consider the Passion Quotient (PQ) and Curiosity Quotient (CQ). It is no longer enough to have just an IQ. To put knowledge into action and to be able to change and adapt, our workforces need all three. Your post demonstrates that for your organization, there is good news – you seem to have all three in spades. Keep learning and keep pushing the envelop.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Amy, as always I have enjoyed sharing a class with you. Your insights are interesting and your writing style is engaging. I, like you, see myself as a networked worker, but the dialog as a part of this course and the readings caused me to think about technology in different ways. Technology touches so many parts of our lives that this course has an overarching impact on my personal and professional life. The reflections seemed to touch me more than in some other courses.

    Your idea of adding the CIO to your leadership decision making process is one that Creighton embraced years ago. The one thing I have seen work extraordinarily well is when the CIO understands the desires of the academic units and provides the technology to facilitate the desires. The one caution I will give is to guard against the technological people having too much power in the decision making process. Technology should not drive decisions. Rather, the technology needs to be the vehicle that enhances the learning experience.

    As we move forward in our professional and personal lives, technology will inevitably shape some of our decisions. I can't fathom what the possibilities are for our youngest children. I fear our iPad will be the "black and white TV" we laugh about with our parents. Please continue the dialog on your campus regarding technology. You are shaping the future of many young and continuing educational learners!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Amy -

    Over the past eight weeks, I think we were each able to take immediate action on something we learned from this course. The inclusion of the CIO on your executive team might be the strongest move anyone was able to make. So cool!

    While we're at it, I think @DWUPrez might be a perfect fit for a Twitter handle? I'm sure you children would be impressed, as would the student-body at DWU. Some of my favorite university presidents on Twitter include...

    Dr. Chuck Ambrose (Central Missouri)
    https://twitter.com/UCMAmbrose

    Dr. John Jasinski (Northwest Missouri)
    https://twitter.com/presidentjazz

    Dr. Robert Manuel (Indianapolis)
    https://twitter.com/UIndyPrez

    Best to you, Amy!
    -Josh

    ReplyDelete